The labour market has been remarkably resilient for a long time. It is now showing more convincing signs of strain. Employment fell by 43,500 in October after dropping by 36,400 in September. It is the first back-to-back decline in a year and the largest two-month fall since October 2021, during the pandemic. Both part-time employment (-40,600) and full-time employment (-2,900) declined, while the participation rate slipped to 66.6%, its lowest this year. Had participation not fallen, the unemployment rate would have been higher.
And this is not just a two-month story. Employment has now fallen in three of the past six months.
The unemployment rate jumped from 4.7% in September to 4.9% in October, its highest since late 2021. That is significant because it has already overtaken the RBA’s 4.7% forecast for the end of this year, published only a fortnight ago. Indeed, October’s 4.9% unemployment rate already matches the RBA’s forecast for the end of 2027.
There is a real risk unemployment breaches 5% before the end of this year. We expect it to reach around 5.5% by the end of next year, alongside GDP growth slowing to just 1.1%. In a weaker scenario, unemployment in the 5.6–6.2% range is possible.
Another labour-market measure reinforces the message. The employment-to-population ratio, which is not directly affected by changes in labour-force participation, fell from 66.8% to 66.3%, its lowest since January 2021.
The numbers also landed amid a run of high-profile job-cut announcements from organisations including David Jones, Bunnings, Qantas, Canva and Woodside Energy. These announcements are too recent to be reflected in October’s employment numbers, but their breadth adds to the sense that conditions in the jobs market are shifting.
The fresh labour-market data was released as I was heading into an industry roundtable with recruiters. The timing could hardly have been better.
Unsurprisingly, AI dominated the discussion. Recruiters spoke about the enormous volume of job applications they are now dealing with, increasingly with the help of their own AI agents. But the conversation went well beyond recruitment. It was also about how quickly businesses and workers can adapt as AI changes the way work is done. The takeaway was simple. Agility matters and some businesses will adapt much better than others.
Skills mismatch remains another challenge. Labour mobility has weakened as Australians become more cautious about leaving secure jobs in an uncertain economy, while cost-of-living pressures are pushing some people towards second jobs. These different forces are colliding just as demand for labour itself appears to be cooling.
The roundtable was in Victoria where unemployment is now the highest among the states (5.4%) and where many businesses are reportedly on pause ahead of the 28 November state election. At the other end sits the “Republic of WA”, as we affectionately called it around the table, with the lowest unemployment rate at 4.5%.
Perhaps the most sobering discussion was about school and university leavers. There was genuine empathy from recruiters for young people trying to get their first break. Graduates increasingly face a familiar catch-22, needing experience to get a job while finding it harder to gain that experience as AI takes on some of the entry-level work that traditionally provided it.
Youth unemployment edged up to 11.3%, its highest since October 2021. AI may ultimately lift productivity and create new types of work, but the transition will not necessarily be smooth, particularly for young people trying to get their foot on the first rung of the career ladder.
Interest-rate markets responded quickly to the labour-market weakness, removing expectations of rate hikes next year and entertaining the possibility of rate cuts arriving sooner. Our central view remains that the RBA’s next move will be a cut, arriving late in the September quarter of 2027. But we are not prepared to completely rule out another increase, putting that risk at around 25-30%.
The complication is inflation. The economy can slow well before inflation follows it down. My worry, and yes, the one that keeps me up at night, is that inflation stays sticky and icky for longer, leaving the RBA caught between a weakening labour market and inflation that refuses to behave.
That brings me to my orthodontist. This week, my orthodontist offered a discount if we took up braces for our youngest before the end of the year. Now, when does an orthodontist do that? Perhaps services disinflation has finally arrived, one set of braces at a time. But it may take some time to know for sure. The removal of card surcharges from 1 October has prompted some businesses to lift headline prices, and in some cases the increase appears to be more than the surcharge it replaced. That could temporarily muddy the inflation signal.
The direction of travel is becoming clearer, even if the inflation story is taking longer to follow. The labour market is weakening and the economy is slowing, but the risk of sticky inflation means the RBA cannot declare victory yet.
For now, expect the RBA to sit on its hands and assess the impact of the five rate rises delivered this year. The economy may be turning faster than inflation, and that is precisely the challenge for the RBA.